Thursday, June 6, 2013

On exploitation of Toy collectors

One of the pitfalls for a start up musician/band is to be exploited off his talents. Picture this. A start up band who is need of gigs will agree to play in front of a paying audience with no pay or just a bottle of beer as payment. Since there is a need to be recognized, the band agrees to this set up. It's fine for a start, but as more gigs pile up with the same set up, the band also spends more time for practice and maintenance of his equipments. The promise of being discovered someday may yet remain the same, a promise. This becomes a cycle. If you don't want to play for free, the event organizer can always get another band who would be willing to play for free. Mind you, most of these bands aren't even playing for the money, but they are playing their music for the love of their craft. But they are easy prey for organizers who could exploit them by using them in their events. Money is still needed if only to sustain the band expenses. And once there is no more money to sustain the hobby, the musician/band quits from developing these talents. Making it just an afterthought of the cruel realities of a money driven world.

This is no different from a Toy Collector. A Toy Collector who owns a good number of collections wants to share his hobby for the love of the hobby and the character that he is collecting. There is also some form of bragging rights once you are able to share (or most of the time show-off) your collections to a larger audience. Such is the simple joy of a collector. TV Networks would come knocking on your door, or invite you to their studio for a feature. Or event organizers would invite you to take part of their events by displaying your collections for the public to see. While these are fine, therein lies the pitfalls of being exploited.

Example number 1, On a regular day, a TV Network invites you to take part in a feature where they want to get a scoop on the hobby of Toy Collecting. You voluntarily agree and a feature is made. This is with no pay and either they invade your home's privacy or you are asked to travel to their studio at your own expense.

Example number 2, there is an upcoming Superman Movie and TV Networks are scrambling to interview/feature Superman collectors for their segment. Again this is with no pay and either they invade your home's privacy or you are asked to travel to their studio at your own expense.

Example 1 may be some sort of exploitation but at least there was an honest effort to feature the hobby. Example 2 on the other hand reeks of commercialism and their ratings war as they know segments like this would drum up viewer interest because of the upcoming movie. This is exploitation.

Toy Collectors mind you don't need the money, because honestly they have the money to spend to amass their collections which are itself not that inexpensive.  But what I'm trying to point out in this entry is that at least TV Networks/Event Organizers should have the decency to give what is due to the volunteers.To give without being coaxed. They could have at least gave a token, an honorarium to defray possible expenses incurred in the transportation of the items or even the precious time of invading your home.

I am writing this entry because I am furious with how I was being treated in an event that I was asked to volunteer for. You see, there's this big event to launch a Superhero Movie and they have come up with an event where they would be asking volunteers to display rare memorabilia of the Superhero. I was asked to volunteer but with no pay. Mind you I don't really need the money, so I was a willing volunteer out of love for the hobby and the character. But then you are asked to do ingress at past 10pm and you reach there with no single showcase cabinet for you to display. What were the organizers thinking? That a volunteer would suppose to stay up until the wee hours of the night or early dawn just to display their collections for free? Good for those who are setting up the event area to stay up late, they are paid. But for us to be asked to stay up late? And we had to coax them just to get those freebies. This is the highest form of exploitation.

And yeah what really infuriated me? It said in their ads and posters that the highlight of the event is the "RARE MEMORABILIA" or for short the Toy Collections and other memorabilia displayed at the event. Our effort was the main attraction for the event to be seen. But that main attraction was not properly compensated. Go Figure.

The point of this entry (or should I see rant) is to educate the Toy Collectors. I don't know if the majority would agree with me but agreeing to appear on TV, display at toy events, or simply being featured for your collections, we should be entitled to have a token, an honorarium, or an appearance fee. Because whether we like it or not, all of those events that we have volunteered for is a MONEY MAKING exercise. They earn from our appearance, from our volunteerism. They earn while we justify our volunteering for the love of the hobby. In short, we are being exploited out of our love for our hobby. And we don't actually get anything from our appearance. At least musicians get a chance to be discovered. But what of us? Now if a few of us demand for just compensation, and yet a good number of toy collectors are willing to volunteer for the same reasons stated above, then there will be no education happening. Just compensation doesn't have to be money. A compensation can come as simple as free tickets, free items, or whatever freebies that the organizer can give. It will then be up to the volunteer if he would accept these freebies as enough.

I urge for those veteran toy collectors who have seen the murky realities of being exploited to impart and educate the new toy collectors or to those who have not yet seen the reality of the exploitation. We need to have a united front in educating those money making/enterprising individuals to give what is due us. Believe me, we must do this so that they would stop bastardizing our hobby. On regular days, they see us as these weird geeks, overgrown children that never outgrew their childhood. On special days, they glorify us because of the collections we have. We must put a stop to this mockery.   

It is absolutely fine for me to volunteer, as long as the event is purely for the betterment of the hobby. And we are not being used in a money making venture. But since almost all events in one form or another is a money making venture. Then, please do give what is due us. Because if there were no toy collections to display, then there would be no toy event to happen in the first place. This ends my entry, and I hope my fellow Toy Collecting brothers got my point.

Feel free to send me your thoughts about this. I would really appreciate it.Thanks!

9 comments:

  1. "On regular days, they see us as these weird geeks, overgrown children that never outgrew their childhood. On special days, they glorify us because of the collections we have. We must put a stop to this mockery."

    This quote brought me to my senses. This is a great Article. Toy Collectors should be aware of this. So we wouldn't be exploited by Corporate Fascists. It's kind of unfair sometimes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Feel free to share and spread the word. Toy collectors and organizers alike needs to be educated.

      Delete
  2. i also love your parting words, man.

    i only became aware of the "featured-collectors-on-a-magazine-show-and-you-are-not-getting-paid" part" through your entry. go figure.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Feel free to share. I think we should make this as our advocacy. We need to set things right here in our country pertaining to this hobby of ours. a lot were already exploited since the Avengers, Iron Man 3, or ever since Superhero movies and toy movies became popular

      Delete
  3. It' s simple. DON'T. ACCEPT. INVITATIONS. This hobby and its enthusiasts have created its own opportunity to be exploited. Since when did collecting become about "bragging" and the incessant need to brandish your merchandise? Wasn't it supposed to be for your own consumption and enjoyment? Since you are so willing to show off your collection, these media outlets will seize the chance to make a buck off of you. To them, collecting is driven by this egotistic need of people "who never outgrew their childhood" to showcase and "brag" their large disposable income. Therefore in their eyes, your desire to be seen on TV with your action figures is enough compensation. It will be NAIVE to think these leeches will care about defraying your "costs" or inconvenience of having to show up to their invitation, which you can freely DECLINE in the first place!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well in my case, it's not about bragging. It's more about helping create awareness for the character. That's why I've never volunteered for Toy Cons and other Events because sometimes these events are for bragging rights. This particular event however was to create awareness for Man of Steel. And as a Superman fan, It was my desire to take part in creating awareness for the movie. And since that was also the point of the event as planned and executed by Warner Phils. and Pacific Merch. It is only right that they compensate the source material for the event to actually be an event. I do understand your point about bragging rights. In my case, I don't need to do that. But I know a lot of collectors do that. My only hope is to organize this thing properly to avoid further exploitation specially Superhero movies seems to be the trend nowadays. More and more Malls would be exploiting this and set up their own exhibits

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  4. This is docronnie.

    OK! Read your article and I agree, but obviously you do not have enough experience. I have appeared a few times on TV since 2001 as a Magician and a Toy collector.

    There are really some shows that do not have enough budget for guests. These are usually the news oriented shows. But if you impose your will, discreetly, and they know that you know how things are done in the studio and tell them all your guesting experiences before, they will take care of you. For sure free breakfast and lunch will be given. Now for shows with budget, you might get an honorarium from 5,000 and above or just tokens and freebies.

    The Lesson: If someone from the TV network approaches you, ask for honorarium immediately. If they have a budget then it's done. If none, for sure you will be taken cared off in terms of meals and probably freebies depending on their sponsors that day.

    Regarding travelling to the studio. You could always request for transportation from the TV network. They will provide this, if they really need you. I noticed not many collectors know this. As a Magician, I always request for transporation, unless if the budget is already enough. In my Kape't Balita stint, I was fetched and taken home by GMA7 and was fed breakfast and snack (lunch?).

    Hero TV featured my Thor collection a few years back. No honorarium, but I got a Red Ribbon Black Forest cake and a copy of my feature. You just have to make friends instantly with the researcher and impose your will, politely.

    Regarding displaying toys in an event. I don't ask any honorarium when I display for the Toycon. Why? Because I get free entrance for 3 days and before, I also get free entrance for my daughter and I get to see the toys that I'm after, before the Toycon opens its doors to the public. Aren't these compensation enough? The organizers also give some freebies once in a while.

    BUT if you're going to display for a movie outfit, which happened to me, well... this is a different case. You have to ask for honorarium immediately! In my case, I was well compensated and Jhambhitz could attest to this, since I gave him a Thor Movie poster! I got an exclusive Thor hammer USB, 2pcs excluve Thor Movie T-shirts and 2pcs Thor Movie posters! :)

    Another thing, as mentioned already, you could always DECLINE. Don't volunteer and just enjoy your collection at home. Peace! :)

    docronnie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for you words of wisdom. But just to be clear, the reason why i wrote this article is to educate. That's why i'm asking veteran toy collectors like you to help educate. No need being antagonistic or sarcastic when replying to this post. Instead, try thinking about concrete solutions how you can help volunteer newbies like me who are rife for exploitation. Why not try to makes some sort of guidelines for the members when they choose to volunteer. Again this is also not about the money or the freebies. What i wanted to point out is that the honorariums should not be asked but presented from to the volunteer from the beginning. It's true that I OBVIOUSLY lack the experience. But how I wish that in the many years of volunteering for displays, someone did the effort to educate us. But thank you Doc Ronnie, your post is helpful.

      Delete